While both feature step-cut faceting, the octagonal cut’s eight sides create additional light return and brilliance, offering greater scintillation while maintaining the sophisticated elegance that step-cut enthusiasts prize. This geometric precision offers a more dynamic appearance while retaining the sophisticated elegance of step cuts, making it particularly appealing for collectors seeking distinctive alternatives to standard shapes. Natural octagonal gemstones typically command higher prices than comparable emerald cuts due to their relative rarity and the additional precision required in cutting, with well-executed examples displaying superior light performance and visual appeal.